Showing posts with label Minnesota Vikings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Minnesota Vikings. Show all posts

Eagles Interview Little-Known Vikings Secondary Coach

Written By Bob Cunningham On Tuesday, February 01, 2011 Comments
According to Howard Eskin of 610WIP, the Eagles have interviewed another candidate for the defensive coordinator job -- Minnesota Vikings secondary coach Joe Woods.

According to Eskin, the interview took place on Monday.

There's not a whole lot known about Woods, but he's received praise from former Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive coordinator Monte Kiffin, the first guy to give Woods a job on his staff in the pros. The Vikings new head coach, Leslie Frazier, has also been quick to dish out the praise for Woods.

The results, however, have not backed up their kind words. It's been long-known that the secondary was the weak link of the Vikings, and without Antoine Winfield -- who was a great player long before Woods entered the picture -- the Minnesota secondary would have been a bottom-half-of-the-league unit at best.


Continue Reading...

Eagles Lose to Vikings, Clinch No. 3 Seed in Playoffs

Written By Bob Cunningham On Wednesday, December 29, 2010 Comments

This was likely the best play Jackson made Tuesday.



Usually I would do a "quick reactions" article, but it's not worth it. To play as poorly as they did this late in the season with a shot at a first-round bye in the playoffs is almost inexplicable, and it's not worth my time to write "(insert name here) was awful tonight" over and over.

Michael Vick was pressing, LeSean McCoy was underutilized, Ernie Sims is still awful, Sean McDermott needs fired, Marty Mornhinweg and Andy Reid combine as the worst play-calling duo in the league, and even David Akers chipped in on the team's horrendous night.

Alright, so there was a quick "quick reactions." We'll discuss those things in greater detail later in the week if I can stomach the thought.

So where do the Eagles stand now after their loss to the Minnesota Vikings?

They already clinched the NFC East once the Green Bay Packers beat the New York Giants, and the only thing left to play for was a shot at getting a first-round bye. They still would have needed the Chicago Bears to fall to the Packers next week along with winning out, but the opportunity was still right in front of them.

I say "was," because they've officially blown that. There is now no way -- even with a Bears loss -- that the Eagles can move up from the third seed. And since the NFC West champion will be, at best, 8-8, the Eagles cannot move down from the third seed.

So, in short, they are the No. 3 seed.

With their spot cemented, they have nothing to play for against the Dallas Cowboys in Week 17, and it presents a dilemma for Reid: does he sit starters like Vick and allow them to be 100 percent when they face the Packers or Giants in the Wild Card round, or does he start them to gain a little bit of a momentum?

When asked at his post-game press conference about sitting starters, Reid said "we're not good enough to do that." That, however, doesn't mean that it's worth risking guys' health (mainly Vick) for a game that means nothing to either team.

In Reid's shoes, I think I would treat the game like the second preseason game. The starters would play for about the first half and the backups would be rotated in slowly from there. Once the fourth quarter started, there wouldn't be a starter on the field.

A decision like this comes down to personal preference. Reid has shown in the past he'll put his starters on the bench when there's nothing to play for, but this is a bit different than in 2004, for example, when they had the No. 1 seed wrapped up after 14 games.

It's certainly something to watch, and I think a short week of practice will be the deciding factor for Reid. If everyone seems healthy, they'll likely play. If someone is banged up, don't be surprised if they're in their streets.

And more to the point, don't be surprised if Kevin Kolb starts.

Continue Reading...

Eagles Final Two Weeks Just Got Hard Again

Written By Bob Cunningham On Sunday, December 26, 2010 1 comments

Thanks snow, you're a day late and the week is FUBAR.



When the schedule first came out, it looked like having to play back-to-back games against the Minnesota Vikings and Dallas Cowboys in the final two weeks of the season would be an absolute nightmare for a team that would be struggling to make the playoffs.

Then, it started to look like a division title had been gift-wrapped by Santa himself.

Brett Favre is banged up (again) and didn't appear likely to play, and the Cowboys were down to their third string quarterback after injuries to Tony Romo and Jon Kitna.

Both teams are in complete disarray, and all the Eagles have to do is beat them for a division title and quite possibly a first-round bye. Should be easy, right?

Not so fast.

With the announcement that the game will be moved from Sunday night to Tuesday night, the Eagles are put at several disadvantages. For one, Favre now has a chance to get healthy. And I don't care if you're the biggest Favre-hater (AKA jackass) on the planet, the guy gives them a much better chance to win than the rookie Joe Webb.

And secondly, Andy Reid's team now must face the Cowboys on a very short week.

Football players are creatures of habit, and this is likely to throw them all out of whack. The practice schedule makes a dramatic shift from here, it gives any player injured against the Vikings on Tuesday less time to recover and that's all compounded by the fact that it's a divisional game.

Divisional games are incredibly difficult regardless of how bad one of the teams actually is. Not to mention the fact that the Cowboys would just love to knock the Eagles out of a first-round bye or division title.

We've been looking for a true barometer of this team for a while now, and I believe we'll get it while watching how they handle what will be a chaotic week.

Continue Reading...

Brian Westbrook Doesn't Seem Likely to Continue Career

Written By Bob Cunningham On Saturday, March 27, 2010 Comments

Brian Westbrook probably has seen his final carry.



It became clear to most Eagles fans that Brian Westbrook was not the same guy he was even only two years ago. He's one of the most popular figures in Philadelphia sports history, so to see the fanbase universally accept that his time was up says a lot.

As is usually the case when a high-profile player is released, everyone started connecting the dots.

Chester Taylor jumped ship for Chicago in free agency, so Minnesota was (and still is) looking for a backup to Adrian Peterson. They looked poised to bring in LaDainian Tomlinson, but that fell through and the Westbrook-to-the-Vikings talks heated up even more.

But there was nothing there. It doesn't appear that the possibility of signing Westbrook even crossed the mind of Minnesota Vikings head coach Brad Childress, who worked with Westbrook for three years as the offensive coordinator in Philadelphia.

He's a perfect fit to backup AP and obviously has a history with Childress, so the fact that there is absolutely no interest says a lot about what even his former coaches think about his ability moving forward.

Even Baltimore Ravens' head coach Jon Harbaugh, once Andy Reid's special teams coordinator, publicly said he would not be pursuing Westbrook.

He said that it was only because he was happy with his situation at running back, which might be true, but it was mainly to be nice to a guy who has been so good for so long, but simply doesn't have it anymore.

There hasn't even been so much as a rumor that Westbrook might be visiting somewhere, much less getting a contract offer any time soon. It's something I think everyone feared when Westbrook was released, but figured that there was even one team out of the 31 remaining that would give him a shot to show he's still got something left.

But there isn't. Barring an injury to a starter somewhere around the league, I don't expect Westbrook to be playing in 2010. And if he doesn't play in 2010, it most likely means that his career is over.

It's an unfortunate end to a man who has been a consummate professional and great player, but that's the way the NFL has gone. It's a "what have you done for me lately?" league, and the truth of matter is that Westbrook hasn't done a whole lot lately.

I hope I'm wrong, but it looks like Westbrook will slowly fade off into the abyss of NFL free agency before he finally is able to come to grips and file the retirement papers.

UPDATE: Brad Childress has officially said he's not interested "as of right this second" in Westbrook.

"He is a good player, and I have a lot of admiration and respect for him," Childress said, according to the Philadelphia Daily News.

"I do not know if we are far enough down the free-agent trail yet, but he is certainly a guy that is on our board and on our list, as are others. There is no interest as of right this second, but do I respect his abilities, absolutely. I have a lot of admiration for him."

Continue Reading...

Does Vikings' Ray Edwards Make Sense for Eagles?

Written By Bob Cunningham On Friday, March 12, 2010 Comments

Is Edwards really an upgrade at left defensive end?



Bob Grotz of the Delaware County Times expects the Eagles to make a push for Minnesota Vikings' defensive end Ray Edwards, a restricted free agent with a first-round tender, but is Edwards really a guy the Eagles should be attempting to acquire?

He set a career mark for sacks this past season with 8.5, but that's while playing next to Jared Allen and the Williams Wall. The real attention put on Edwards has been because of his three-sack performance against the Dallas Cowboys in the Divisional round of the 2009 playoffs.

While it was impressive, it's important that teams keep things in perspective. Playing on such a great line gives him a lot of opportunities for one-on-one matchups and he wasn't even able to hit double-digit sacks.

He's got great size (6'5, 270) and would benefit from having Trent Cole on the other side, but Edwards' lack of production in the regular season is cause for concern. To me, it says he either lacks the talent or the work ethic necessary to become a great player.

A guy like Edwards always takes me back to what Brian Dawkins once said about Clinton Hart; When a guy only shows flashes of talent, it just means he's not working hard enough.

It's a statement so simplistic and obvious in nature that it's genius. Showing flashes clearly means that the talent is there, but the player isn't putting in the time and effort it would take to bring everything together consistently.

That is Edwards in a nutshell, and I think it's going to cause a lot of teams to shy away from him. He's very good for what the Vikings have right now because he has shown that he can produce when called upon, but a lot of his success directly correlates to the presence of the three great players next to him.

And for those who think he would be better than what the Eagles already have in Juqua Parker, consider that Edwards had 8.5 sacks to Parker's eight. Is an extra half of a sack really worth a draft pick and about $4-6 million per season?

Continue Reading...

Donovan McNabb Will Not Become a St. Louis Ram

Written By Bob Cunningham On Thursday, March 04, 2010 Comments

The talks of McNabb to St. Louis are 100 percent false.



All this talk of Donovan McNabb to St. Louis is ridiculous. ProFootballTalk.com seems to be the main culprit behind these rumors, and like most rumors they back it up with absolutely nothing.

No sources, no inside scoop, not even so much as a logical explanation as to why it would make sense. Not only that, but they're completely ignoring multiple reports that the Rams haven't even called the Eagles about any of their quarterbacks at this point.

The reality is that the move doesn't make sense for any of the three parties involved. McNabb is 33 years old and wants to win a ring -- he won't do that in St. Louis and everyone knows it. The Rams are in an obvious rebuilding mode, so why would they even want a quarterback McNabb's age?

And why would the Eagles move a quarterback of McNabb's caliber for the first pick in the second round? It's far below what McNabb is worth, and the Eagles would be foolish to even think about it.

The first pick in the second round (33rd overall) sounds like a good pick, but when you consider the fact that there's only about 20-25 players given a "first round grade" every year, anything past that essentially becomes a second round pick because the talent level no longer justifies the slotting of the pick.

If a team wants McNabb, it's going to have to not only be a first round pick, but a mid-level first round pick.

This is really just playing devil's advocate on my part since I don't believe that the Eagles are really looking to trade McNabb anyway, but they're certainly not going to trade him just for the sake of trading him.

If Big Red isn't blown off his chair by the offer, McNabb stays put.

The only teams McNabb would consider signing an extension with anyway are the Arizona Cardinals and Minnesota Vikings. Those are the only two teams with a realistic shot at the playoffs and the Super Bowl every season, and also need a quarterback.

Arizona would also make sense for McNabb because that's where he lives.

But the Eagles aren't ever going to allow that to happen. They're not going to give someone in their own conference the means to knock them off in the playoffs with their own quarterback.

So what we've learned (and really already knew but just like to ignore) is that McNabb will only sign with a good team, but the Eagles won't trade him to a good team. They want to trade him to a rebuilding team, but McNabb won't sign with a rebuilding team.

Or, in other words, McNabb isn't going anywhere.

Continue Reading...

Brian Westbrook to Rejoin Brad Childress in Minnesota?

Written By Bob Cunningham On Wednesday, February 24, 2010 Comments

Could Westbrook be running with the Vikings in '10?



Almost immediately after Brian Westbrook's release from the Eagles, the rumors started swirling as to which teams are interested, who's not, how much it will take to get him, how he will be used, and everything else.

But to me, the most likely landing spot would be the Minnesota Vikings with his former offensive coordinator, Brad Childress.

Childress is obviously now the head coach in Minnesota, and the Vikings will be looking for a change-of-pace back behind Adrian Peterson. Chester Taylor is almost guaranteed to be elsewhere next season, so running back will be a focus for the Vikings.

The only question is whether Childress would be interested in his former running back, or if he'll be looking to get younger through the draft.

It would make sense that Childress would be interested in Westbrook because not only does he know him personally and has a player, but Westbrook fits a specific need. The Vikings don't just need a backup running back, they need a guy who can catch the ball out of the backfield and pass protect on third down.

Westbrook may be the best pass-catching running back since Roger Craig, and is known throughout the league for his pass blocking.

Not only that, but Westbrook might be able to help Peterson with his fumbling problems.

"Not a single running back in NFL history has more yards from scrimmage (9,785) with fewer fumbles than Brian Westbrook (12). And Westbrook's rate of one fumble every 144 touches is the best mark by a running back in NFL history (minimum 1,500 touches)," writes fellow blogger Bryn Swartz.

A one-year deal with a low base salary laced with incentives could get Westbrook to Minnesota, but without at least a two-year deal, he could just retire.

He has said that he's afraid of the lasting effects of concussions on players, and if he's not going to make all that much money, he could just hang it up.

He most certainly wants a ring, however, so while that's a possibility, I would say the chances are very low.

Teams like the Atlanta Falcons, Cincinnati Bengals, and New Orleans Saints could emerge as dark horses, but good money says Westbrook follows his former coach, the place where he fits best, and where he has the best chance of winning a Super Bowl, and Minnesota fits all those needs.

Continue Reading...

Eagles Would Benefit Immensely from Uncapped 2010

Written By Bob Cunningham On Tuesday, February 02, 2010 Comments

Was Eagles' loss to Dallas really a blessing in disguise?



While I believe that an uncapped season in 2010 would be an overall bad thing for the NFL, it could turn out to be a great thing for our Philadelphia Eagles.

Because of the "top eight rule," which says that the teams playing in the Divisional Round of the playoffs cannot sign a free agent without first losing a player, the Eagles will face much less competition for anyone they decide to target in free agency, restricted or otherwise.

Think about it. If a free agent has a choice of somewhere to go, especially with teams like New Orleans, Indianapolis, Dallas, Arizona, San Diego, and Minnesota off the table, the Eagles would become the next obvious choice for someone looking to play for a contender.

On top of attracting free agents, the Eagles will not have to offer contract extensions to keep key players like Leonard Weaver, Jason Avant, or Nick Cole. Instead, they will have a bevy of restricted free agents that will be of interest to other teams around the league.

And if those teams want one of the Birds' eight restricted free agents, it will take a draft pick or two.

So, if we want to look at the cup as half-full, the loss to the Cowboys during Wild Card weekend could actually turn out to be the best thing for the Birds.

They're already on par with, or better than, the four NFC teams mentioned, and all-but eliminating them as competition for free agents should be able to help them pull ahead or widen the gap for 2010.

Continue Reading...

Vikings Do What the Eagles Could Not vs. Dallas

Written By Bob Cunningham On Sunday, January 17, 2010 Comments

Romo was abused all game long by the Vikings' defense.



Everyone knew how to stop the Dallas Cowboys, it was just a matter of finding a team who could execute the gameplan properly.

Putting pressure on Tony Romo is basically where that gameplan begins and ends, but thanks to a very good Cowboys' offensive line, that plan is easier said than done. However, for the teams that can accomplish it, it should mean a certain victory.

The Eagles were able to get a little bit of pressure on Romo in the Wild Card game after not even making him flinch in Week 17, but it wasn't enough. The Vikings, on the other hand, were able to get in Romo's face all day and force him to move around inside the pocket.

And "inside the pocket" is the most important part.

Allowing Romo to get outside of the pocket might be more dangerous than not getting any pressure on him. When he's outside of the pocket he's able to look down the field, usually with no one around him, and is also a threat to run. The threat to run then takes a half-step away from the secondary and can lead to a big play.

But the Vikings, with a huge day from Ray Edwards, were able to use their defensive ends to keep him in the pocket, then take advantage of his indecisiveness. The pass rush led to six team sacks, three by Edwards, an interception, and three Romo fumbles -- two of which were lost.

Three turnovers for Romo and six sacks crushed his confidence and had him running scared all game long, which in turn led to good field position and all the momentum for the Vikings. The Vikings offense took full advantage and abused a Cowboys defense with its back against the wall.

In other words, the Vikings did everything that I had hoped the Eagles would do, but inevitably fell short of those goals. The lack of starting-caliber talent at linebacker and the lack of a pass-rushing left defensive end were the downfalls of Birds, but is something that the Vikings clearly possess.

It would have been nice to abuse the 'Boys the way the Vikings did, but if it couldn't be our Eagles, I'm satisfied to see it was a former Eagle in Vikings' head coach Brad Childress. Childress and Andy Reid still speak quite often and keep in touch, so I'd bet that Reid asked Childress to lay it on the Cowboys.

Hence the fourth quarter touchdown pass by Brett Favre to run up the score.

Maybe I'm giving them the kiss of death, but I'm now officially supporting the Vikings to take it all the way and win one for the NFC. If you've been visiting the site for a little while you know that I'm a Favre supporter, so let's win one for the gipper, Minnesota.

Continue Reading...

Minnesota Vikings Sign Former Eagles WR Greg Lewis

Written By Bob Cunningham On Friday, September 11, 2009 Comments

Greg Lewis' catch that will forever be etched in Philly fans' minds.


Greg Lewis is headed to his third team in his career, and his second this offseason. After being cut by the New England Patriots, he has joined the Minnesota Vikings.

New England had traded for Lewis, but apparently they were not happy with their acquisition and decided to cut the career backup. Minnesota, on the other hand, was apparently not happy with Bobby Wade (who was the team's leading receiver the past two seasons) and recently cut him.

Brad Childress has made a habit of at least looking at former Eagles players, and now he's brought one in. Childress was the offensive coordinator for the Eagles while Greg Lewis was there, so G-Lew comes in already having a rapport with the head coach.

G-Lew probably won't be anything more than the fourth or fifth receiver, but he has flashed some ability during his time with the Eagles and will contribute to the Vikings, even if that contribution is minimal.

He wasn't a great receiver, but G-Lew will never be forgotten in Philly because of his touchdown reception in Super Bowl 39. His legacy is like FredEx without the stupid press conferences.

Continue Reading...

Former Eagles OC Brad Childress Could Be Committing Career Suicide

Written By Bob Cunningham On Monday, August 17, 2009 Comments

If he wants to stay in purple, he'll keep Favre out of purple.


Brad Childress has done a good job with Minnesota since arriving in the 2006 season. During his time there, the Vikings have increased their win total by two each season (from six, to eight, to ten last year including a division title), and have become legitimate playoff and even Super Bowl contenders.

However, his handling of the Favre situation could kill not only his sustained success in Minnesota, but his job as the Vikings' head coach.

I thought the way he handled Favre during the period of "Favre Watch" and the permanent Hattiesburg, MI assignment of several ESPN field reporters was just fine. He was very vague with the media, which is good for a situation like that, and he threw all of his chips into the pot in an attempt to go after a Hall of Fame quarterback.

While it didn't work out, I think it shows his committment to winning and taking the Minnesota franchise to a place it has been been in several decades. He has Tarvaris Jackson and Sage Rosenfels, but the only people in the country who think they're good enough to take the Vikings to the Super Bowl are themselves. Which is important, but misguided.

Unfortunately the Vikings and everyone else has realized that the quarterback position is a real weakness for the Vikings, as neither quarterback has had sustained success as a starter. Therefore, the pursuit of Favre makes perfect sense. Or rather, made perfect season.

Now, however, it's time to shut and deadbolt the door on a Favre return to Minnesota.

While Childress did a good job of staying noncommittal either way on the Favre story earlier, he has since said that beyond a shadow of a doubt the door for Favre to become a Viking is closed. When a head coach makes such a concrete statement, they have no choice but to stick with it or risk their credibility with the media, and most importantly, the team, being compromised.

I'm sure Childress didn't just make that statement to the media, but to his team and to the quarterbacks he's working with at the moment. I'm sure he gathered them all together either in the locker room or a meeting room and told them that Favre will not be a Viking and told Jackson and Rosenfels that the job will belong to one of them.

To go back on that now would be the very definition of career suicide.

In the world of pro football, all a head coach has to speak for him are his actions. He must always stick to his word with his players because if they do not trust him, the team will suffer on the field. There is no possible way for a team to be successful when the guys are not a cohesive, trusting unit which goes all the way to the head coach, GM, and the owner.

Lying to the media is one thing, and really, I don't have too much of a problem with it. The media will twist and distort most stories anyway, so in some instances they deserve it. For instance, a lot of people are still reporting that McNabb had no say in the Vick signing, when he has made it quite clear that he started the discussion. However, that's not a story like a McNabb-Vick fight.

Based on the comments of the Vikings players it's safe to assume that Childress has told them that the door for Favre is shut and that they're moving on. The quotes of anonymous players are really quite a flimsy source, and should be taken with a grain of salt, but if the quotes are really from players, Childress may already have lost that locker room.

If he wants any chance of keeping his job in Minnesota he must shut down any Favre talks in the locker room, and he must do that by sticking to his word that Favre will not be wearing purple in 2009. If he goes back on his word now, he will lose his job in Minnesota, and may never see a head coaching opportunity, at least in the NFL, ever again.

Continue Reading...

As I Said Before, Brett Favre Is Staying Retired

Written By Bob Cunningham On Tuesday, July 28, 2009 Comments

This is the Brett Favre that most will remember.


Nearly two months ago when this whole thing started, I said that I did not believe Favre would be playing again in 2009.

Apparently, I was right.

Tom Curran and Jay Glazer are reporting that Favre has called Brad Childress to inform him that he will not be coming back to the NFL, and more specifically to the Vikings, in 2009, and most likely ever again.

Right now all of the sports betting websites are having a huge rush on the "When will Brett Favre change his mind?" question of the day. Not to mention the over/under on the Vikings season without Favre, or how many years Childress sticks around the Minnesota area.

To any of you betters out there, put your money on Brett not making a return. I said this two months ago, and I'll say it again, Favre still wants to play, sure. Most guys retire from the NFL when they still feel mentally capable of playing the game, but Favre also understands that he can no longer rely on his body to hold up for 16+ games.

I've been on record for years saying that I believe Favre is the greatest quarterback to ever buckle a chinstrap, and I still stand by that. Several NFL parlay picks were already in place for the Vikings to make a run at the Super Bowl, so it shows what kind of respect the man has.

Even the people who don't really follow football, but are more into the gambling side of it, know and understand the kind of difference that Favre's presence can make for a football team.

Hopefully now this will end all of the nonsensical talk of Favre as a "prima donna" or whatever else the media is spouting just to create a stir and grab a couple cheap headlines. He wanted to play, he like the Vikings know that he wanted to play, but in the end he made the right decision.

While this is what people think of when they think of Brett Favre right now, in five years (when he's in the Hall of Fame) all anyone will remember were his 16 years with the Green Bay Packers.

In fact, most may not even remember his year with the Jets, or his year with the Falcons for that matter.

Quick trivia to prove a point: What teams did Joe Montana, Joe Namath, and Johnny Unitas finish their careers with?

Now honestly, how many of you know that answers without "Googling" it?

Continue Reading...

An Army Needs a General: A Closer Look at the NFL's Quarterback Battles

Written By Bob Cunningham On Thursday, June 11, 2009 Comments

Alex Smith and Shaun Hill prepare to do battle.


Of all the positional battles that take place in the offseason, none captivate us more than that of the quarterback battle.

Quarterback may be the most overrated position in all of sports. They get far too much of the blame, and far too much of the credit. Their careers are looked at in terms of Super Bowl victories rather than any other accomplishment, while no other position is looked at in that same light.

How often do you hear, "Yes, he was a great safety. But how many Super Bowls did he win?"

Not often. But, that's a different discussion for a different day.

Having multiple quarterbacks competing for the position usually means bad things for that franchise. As the old saying goes, "If you have two quarterbacks, you have no quarterback."

This can also be said for women, but again, a different discussion for a different day.

The battle is on to see who will lead their respective team, and it's taking place in quite a few teams this offseason. There are more battles now than I can remember taking place before, which shows the shallow talent pool for quarterbacks these days.

Team-by-team, player-by-player, who turns overnight celebrity, and who holds the clipboard?

San Francisco: Alex Smith vs. Shaun Hill

Everyone knows Alex Smith as the bust of the 2005 draft, and arguably the biggest bust of this decade.

Even though he's already been labeled, it looks as though Smith will get the chance to show that the 49ers were right to pass on players like DeMarcus Ware, Shawn Merriman, and Aaron Rodgers to choose him.

It's no secret that the only reason that Smith is even getting this shot is because of all the money invested in him, and because it will create a bit of a stir for a franchise that has had a hard fall from the mountain peak all the way back to sea level.

Shaun Hill was very productive last year for then-interim head coach Mike Singletary. In only eight starts, Hill completed nearly 63 percent of his passes and threw for more than 2,000 yards with 13 touchdowns, to only eight interceptions and posting a 5-3 record.

Smith, on the other hand, hasn't been half as productive in his 30 career starts.

While Hill is the obvious choice in this battle, Smith may become the starter Week One simply because of his prior draft status, and because for better or for worse, he has a recognizable name. Most people outside of the San Francisco Bay have never even heard of Hill (an undrafted guy in the same year Smith was taken No. 1 overall).

Smith, however, could see himself get yanked if Week 1 is a disaster. In other words he may get "Charlie-Fryed."

Tampa Bay: Byron Leftwich vs. Josh Freeman vs. Luke McCown

Leftwich was brought in as a free agent, McCown was retained before hitting free agency, and Josh Freeman was the 17th overall pick in the 2009 draft.

I thought Jon Gruden was in the booth now for Monday Night Football?

The McCown signing doesn't make much sense to me, as he's really been nothing more than a backup for his career, and the Bucs have plenty of those.

They need a starter, and the only guy ready to step in right now and do that is Leftwich.

I've been incredibly shocked at how little attention was paid to Leftwich since the Steelers allowed him to hit the free agent market. Leftwich is a proven guy who has won games in this league, and at the same time is still a young veteran.

For my money, he has the talent to become a franchise quarterback. Whether he will or not is another story.

The plan in Tampa should be to play Leftwich for as long as possible, and allow Freeman to take the reigns in two years. The plan could change if Leftwich plays the way that I believe he can, but the Bucs will have a very hard time not playing their first round draft choice as soon as possible.

I say Leftwich wins this battle easily and holds it down for at least the next year and a half to two years.

Minnesota: Sage Rosenfels vs. Tarvaris Jackson

Notice there is not a third name. I do not believe there will be a third quarterback competing for this spot.If I'm wrong, that third quarterback steps in and there is no competition. Make a mental note.

Rosenfels and Jackson have both had their moments where they looked like they could become decent starters, but have also looked like they don't even belong in the league.

Rosenfels playing helicopter with the Colts defense doesn't help his cause, and Jackson's decision-making ability has been nothing but the ability to make bad decisions.

This may be the most confusing quarterback battle in the league, considering how widely inconsistent both quarterbacks are.

If one of these guys can finally play with some consistency, they will pull out the win. However the odds of that happening aren't great.

Rosenfels is probably the more polished quarterback, and Vikings fans would rather see a guy who hasn't already messed up their team, so I'm going out on a limb and saying Rosenfels will be the Week One starter.

That, of course, does not mean he'll be starter in Week Two.

Detroit: Matthew Stafford vs. Daunte Culpepper

Matthew Stafford is the future of the Lions' franchise. Really, it's not a question of if, but rather when he will be taking the reigns.

The guy has a guaranteed $42 million coming his way, whether he plays or not, so I'm assuming he'll be playing as quickly as possible.

That being said, it would be a huge mistake for the Lions to start Stafford right away. That's not to say that quarterbacks who start their rookie season can't be successful in that season, or even later in their career (Troy Aikman, Peyton Manning, Ben Roethlisberger, Vince Young, etc.).

However, the difference is the time those quarterbacks came out of college. They all came out after their senior year, whereas Stafford opted out of his senior year to come to the NFL.

Junior quarterbacks have had very little success in the NFL, with the most successful of them being Drew Bledsoe. Bledsoe appeared in a Super Bowl, but never won one, and really never lived up to the hype or the potential.

If Stafford starts Week One, not only will the Lions be throwing him into an awful situation, but they'll be ensuring that his success in the NFL is limited.

Not only that, but why start a rookie when they have a proven vet ready to step in and play now? Culpepper may not be the same since his knee injury, but he's a more-than-capable quarterback, especially for a Lions team just looking to make it through a rebuilding year.

If the Lions are smart, and if Shwartz wants to keep his job longer than Cam Cameron, Culpepper will be under center Week One, and hopefully the entire year. Give Stafford a year to sit and learn before you give him the keys.

Denver: Kyle Orton vs. Chris Simms

This time last year, no one would have guessed that Denver would have been on the list of teams with a quarterback competition but, here they are.

Josh McDaniels has come in and gotten rid of the first franchise quarterback that the city had seen since John Elway, and has opened up a competition between two quarterbacks in their first season with this team.

The silver lining is that both of these quarterbacks have been starters on other teams, and have won some games.

Simms looked like he was making strides in Tampa until that horrific hit which caused his spleen to rupture and later be removed. If Jon Gruden ever committed to a quarterback, it was Simms. Unfortunately, it didn't work out, and he found himself as a backup in Tennessee before signing on this offseason with Denver.

Orton was a starter for the Bears last season before coming to Denver in the trade involving former Broncos starter Jay Cutler.

Orton has been involved in quarterback competitions before, namely with former first-round pick Rex Grossman. Orton beat out Grossman last season and played admirably with the Bears, but he's not a franchise quarterback, so he was deemed expendable in the trade for Cutler.

Orton is certainly the more polished quarterback between the two, but is having a difficult time holding off the son of Phil Simms. Simms will definitely give Orton a run for his money, but in the end I believe the winner will be Orton because he's got a much better pocket presence than Simms.

Simms could make a late push to overtake Orton as the starter, but he would have to be phenomenal in the preseason in order for that to occur at this point.

Both quarterbacks must go into this knowing that they're on a very short leash, and should the team start to lose, their job is anything but secure.

Oakland: JaMarcus Russell vs. Jeff Garcia

The Raiders have stockpiled quarterbacks this offseason, but the likes of Andrew Walters, Charlie Frye, and Bruce Gradkowski are not enough to compete with a proven winner in Jeff Garcia, and a former first overall pick ready to explode with potential in JaMarcus Russell.

Garcia is in the same unenviable position as Shaun Hill in San Francisco. While Garcia is obviously the better quarterback of the two, he will have to really outshine Russell in order to get the nod.

The Raiders understand that benching Russell at this point would probably ruin him mentally and therefore as a quarterback entirely. However, they also understand that this fanbase wants to win now.

Russell certainly has a higher ceiling than Garcia, but also could fall right through the basement floor at any given moment.

With Garcia under center and having that fantastic running game behind him, the Raiders are guaranteed, in my mind, at least five or six wins, if not more. With Russell under center, no one has any idea what could happen. They could see another 2-14 season, or make the playoffs in a weak division.

No one knows.

I think Russell has to win this, because if he doesn't it means that the Raiders no longer see him as the future of the franchise. The Raiders are not ready to give up on him just yet, and it will be his job to lose.

Of course with Russell, he may do just that.

Kansas City: Matt Cassel vs. Tyler Thigpen vs. Brodie Croyle

This is a battle that no one outside of Kansas City is talking about, but one that should be mentioned.

Anyone who believes that Todd Haley is simply going to insert Matt Cassel into the starting role just because of what was given up to attain him his dead wrong.

Haley is looking for the best guy to run his offense and if that turns out to be Thigpen or Croyle, then so be it.

Thigpen stepped in and played well for the Chiefs last year. He gave that offense a certain unexpected explosiveness that Brodie Croyle could not.

In 11 starts last season, Thigpen was able to throw for more than 2,500 yards along with 18 touchdowns to 13 interceptions. While those numbers aren't stellar, they're certainly better than what most would have expected from a former-seventh round pick on a poor team such as the Chiefs.

With a great team around him, Cassel was able to throw for more than 3,500 yards with 21 touchdowns to 11 interceptions. So in five more games played, Cassel with able to throw for only 1,000 yards more, three more touchdowns and only two fewer interceptions.

Cassel threw to Wes Welker and Randy Moss. Thigpen threw to Dwayne Bowe and Tony Gonzalez, a tight end.

I'd say the only thing that Cassel has over Thigpen is the hype.

Notice Brodie Croyle hasn't gotten much of a mention. While he'll be given a shot, he's never been able to stay healthy, and this year will probably be no exception.

Don't expect much from Croyle in the way of giving either of these guys any real competition.

Cleveland: Derek Anderson vs. Brady Quinn

To me, this is a pretty obvious choice. Anderson has shown that he can throw for nearly 30 touchdowns and lead this team to the brink of a playoff berth. A berth they may have earned had Charlie Frye not been there to tank Week One.

Quinn, on the other hand, was nothing special during the time he saw last season. He did not show the poise, the leadership, or the decision-making skills that a quarterback must have in order to be successful.

To be fair, Quinn has seen limited time and should not be judged just yet. Anderson has shown what he can do, and he's shown that he can be quite good.

Anderson was the victim of Braylon Edwards last season. There were several times where had Edwards just caught a perfectly thrown ball, the team may have won, and Anderson may have been able to keep his job. Couple that with an aging Jamal Lewis, and you have a guy in Anderson who took far too much of the blame.

Perhaps with a rejuvenated Edwards, Anderson can regain his Pro Bowl form and show the team why they paid him the big bucks.

The team is in quite a bind with these two. On one hand, they did give Anderson a lucrative contract after his '07 season. On the other they did move up to draft Quinn in the first round.

This could wind up being the closest of the battles, with the decision probably not coming until the fourth week of the preseason.

Mangini should choose wisely. His job will depend on his selection.

If he's smart, he'll choose Anderson. Quinn's just not ready yet.

New York (Jets): Mark Sanchez vs. Kellen Clemens

Rex Ryan certainly will have his hands full with this one.

Unlike in Detroit, the Jets do not have a proven veteran to play while Sanchez holds the clipboard and learns the ropes. They have Kellen Clemens, a guy who has seen limited time and barely qualifies as a veteran.

Sanchez has a lot of potential, but has very limited playing time as well, even in college. His 16 college starts amount to one full NFL season, and if that's all the games the Jets are playing, Sanchez will see a fanbase turning on him very quickly.

While I'm a firm believer in sitting a rookie quarterback, especially a guy who came out as a junior, the Jets may not have a choice with Sanchez. Their best bet may be to throw him in now and see what he can do.

The situations with Stafford and Sanchez are not quite the same, as Sanchez has a much better team around him. The Jets are a .500 team even without a quarterback, so Sanchez should be able to thrive with some talented guys around him.

Thomas Jones, Leon Washington, Jerricho Cotchery, and Dustin Keller to name a few, are guys who can help support Sanchez in his transition to the NFL.

The Jets should hope that Clemens steps up and takes command, because if he doesn't the Jets will have a very hit-or-miss type of season while having to deal with a rookie quarterback and their usual roller-coaster progression through the season.

Also, don't get spoiled by Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco. As far as rookie quarterbacks go, their seasons were an aberration in a league that does not treat rookies, especially rookie quarterbacks, kindly.


Continue Reading...

A Final Effort to Protect Brett Favre's Legacy as One of the Best

Written By Bob Cunningham On Thursday, May 07, 2009 Comments
Reports are coming out now that nothing has come from the meeting between former New York Jets quarterback Brett Favre and Minnesota Vikings head coach Brad Childress.

But no matter what is said or reported, no one seems to believe it. Everyone has their own ideas, but the majority opinion seems to be that he will play in 2009.

No one believes Favre when he says he's retired, which I agree with. But only to a point.

As far as I'm concerned the situations of last offseason and this year's offseason are night and day.

In Green Bay, it was fairly obvious that Ted Thompson/Mike McCarthy wanted Favre gone to make way for Aaron Rodgers. After Favre's obviously sub-par season in 2005 (20 TD's to 29 INT's), he thought Favre would have been gone by 2006, and certainly by 2007.

Unfortunately for Thompson/McCarthy, Favre played too well to warrant getting rid of or benching him.

2006 was not a great year for Favre (18 TD's to 18 INT's), but he led a bad team to a .500 record that year, and set the platform for success in 2007.

The story of 2007 is a well-known one. Favre, at 38 years old, led the packers to a 13-3 record and to the NFC Championship game on his arm and a late-season breakout by Ryan Grant.

Let's not forget that for the first 10 games of the 2007 season, Favre had thrown more passes than any quarterback in the league and the Packers had the most lop-sided run-pass ratio in the NFL. At some points reaching 80%-20%.

Regardless of having absolutely no running game for over half the year, Favre played like he was in his late-20's rather than late-30's.

With 28 TD's and only 15 INT's Favre was in talks for MVP through the entire year, and did in fact earn a few votes.

Unfortunately for Favre, no one remembers the fact that he led a decent team to a year where they overachieved. That was fairly obvious to anyone really paying attention. The only thing anyone remembers was his lollipop interception to seal the loss against the Giants.

All the Favre-haters conveniently forget the fact that he had thrown for five touchdowns to only two interceptions during the postseason with a 99.0 quarterback rating, or the fact that Ryan Grant fumbled the ball away twice in one game.

No, the only thing brought up is the interception. I'm not here to defend the pass, it was a bad pass, but considering the man was 80% of the reason they were there in the first place, I think he deserves some slack for that.

But regardless of the fact that Favre was the biggest reason for the Packers' success, Thompson/McCarthy had watched their golden-boy hold a clipboard for far too long, leading to his storied trade to the New York Jets.

During that well-publicized offseason, the Packers did all they could to make Favre look like the bad guy in order to temper some of the backlash that they knew they would receive if Favre was wearing any colors other than green and yellow.

You must tip your hat to Thompson, the man did his job in that regard.

Favre was made to look like this evil child holding his parents hostage until he decided they were allowed to be let go, and that's simply not the case.

Favre was pressured by Thompson and McCarthy into making a decision, and making it quickly.

The same happened to Marino after the 1999 season when Dave Wannstedt came in with the crazy idea that Marino was washed up and convinced him to retire. Like Thompson/McCarthy, Wannstedt was in no way married to Marino and wanted his own guy (by the way, Jay Fiedler was great).

Favre, like Marino, obliged and came to the decision that he felt was the proper one at the time, and that was to retire.

I believe that when Favre gave his now-infamous retirement speech at his press conference, that he really believed he couldn't take it anymore. He felt as though the pressures of the offseason were simply too much for him to handle any longer.

However, had he been given the time to think and make a decision, he would never have retired, and this would not even be an issue.

Instead, the man who helped bring the Packers back to relevancy for the first time since the departure of Vince Lombardi and Bart Starr, was treated like a scrub who had done nothing for the organization.

However, what was done was done. Brett Favre was now a New York Jet and they immediately became Super Bowl favorites in a lot of football circles.

And why? Because they had Brett Favre. Speaks to the man's reputation a bit, doesn't it? A team that missed the playoffs the previous year is being talked about in the Super Bowl because they brought in this one guy. Not bad.

Once again, Favre had his team overachieving.

Anyone who believes the Jets were a .500 team before Favre arrived is living in a revisionist's history fantasy world.

The Jets had made some improvements here and there and were definitely a better team, but they were a couple years away from being considered legitimate playoff contenders.

But Favre did what he always does, and that's win. If you doubt that, just look at the man's record. Only in one year did he have a losing season, and that was 2005 (4-12) with a putrid team around him. Up until then, the worst he had done was 8-8.

Does anyone really believe that if Kellen Clemens was under center that the Jets would have even sniffed 9-7? Or that Thomas Jones would have been able to have the year that he had?

The answer to both is no. Clemens may be a decent quarterback one day, but he doesn't hold a candle to Favre (never will), and the only reason Jones had the year that he had was because Favre's presence would not allow the defense to stack eight men in the box and focus only on him.

They had to respect Brett Favre.

Jones loved criticizing Favre and running his mouth, but he'll be missing him big time when Mark Sanchez doesn't even make a defense blink and he's brought back down to earth.

But again, even with the Jets, Favre was in MVP talks and everyone was praising Tennenbaum for bringing him to New York, until the injury.

Favre tore a bicep in his arm and wasn't the same for the last four or five games of the season, but how many quarterbacks could be? Elway played extremely well with the same injury, but Elway was an exception and didn't rely on his arm strength in the same way that Favre did.

But in typical Favre fashion, he played through it.

Did you ever hear Favre blame a bad game on his arm? Never. But still there were calls to bench him, and I won't even argue that. I do believe that you allow a player of his caliber to try and work it out because even injured he's far and away better than anything on the bench.

But instead of Mangini catching the heat for deciding to leave him in, Favre caught heat and was called a selfish person for continuing to play.

What?!

He's a selfish person because he's fighting through injury to do everything he can to help his team win? That hardly makes any sense. The case could be mad that perhaps he was hurting the team because he wasn't the same, but that's not his call to make. Any self-respecting football player will never pull themselves out of a game.

That is on the coach to decide.

For example, this year Donovan McNabb was not playing well for a stretch of a couple games. He got pulled by the head coach. He was angry because regardless of how you're playing you never want to be pulled and no player (well, no good player) will ever do that to themselves.

But this offseason, after the injury and getting attacked relentlessly by any writer who wanted a story and wanted to cause a stir, he has decided that it's time to hang up the cleats.

I believe that this is the real deal. Favre has been given time to think about it and come to a decision without any pressure. In fact, new head coach Rex Ryan and owner Woody Johnson said they would have loved to have him back for another season. Apparently, they're the only guys who get it.

If Favre comes back again, he deserves every bit of criticism that the media and fans can lay on him because this team it's all on him.

However, he's made his decision now and I believe he will do just as he told Brad Childress and stay retired.

The point is that Favre played the game simply to play the game. He didn't play for the money or the fame, and he's not this "Prima Donna" everyone believes he is. He's the guy throwing a touchdown in the backyard and carry his receiver around the field for a victory lap on his shoulders.

He should be a guy who's looked at as a role model. A man who had a bout with prescription drugs and alcohol, but he beat it. He overcame his problems and became one of the best quarterbacks, if not the best, to ever play the game.

He put it all on the line, hurt or not. He did whatever he could to help his team win and 63% (his winning percentage, 169-100) of the time it worked like a charm. He was an unorthodox player but the job got done, and it got done extremely well.

Perhaps instead of mocking John Madden (another disrespected football icon) for his admiration of Brett Favre, everyone should follow suit and recognize the man's importance and contribution to not only the NFL, but the game of football.

So to Brett Favre: Stay in Hattiesburg and enjoy your Hall of Fame election in five years. I hear Hattiesburg, Mississippi is a great place to be in October. Well, better than Minnesota at least.


Continue Reading...

Enter your email address to receive the best Philly sports news and analysis on the web!:

Delivered by FeedBurner

For the best in Philadelphia sports, look no further than Belmont.com. They've got you covered for all American sports wagering offering unparalleled customer service and fast payouts to the customers.

DISCLAIMER:

This site is strictly for informational and entertainment purposes, and is in no way affiliated with the National Football League or the Philadelphia Eagles. It also claims no rights to the trademarks of the NFL or Philadelphia Eagles.

2 Minutes to Midnight Green also claims no copyright to any photos used.